A Word On Benedetto’s Father Figures

A word on Benedetto’s father figures

Because I’ve been thinking about it all week. Have some parallels and contrasts, my friends:

Villefort:

Starts off Benedetto’s story extremely strongly by literally burying him alive within minutes of his birth. No one has ever failed their son harder.

Might have been onto something when he said crime spread around him and from him like a disease. Seriously, look at this family! It’s so dysfunctional in so many ways!!! If you’re a nature-over-nurture person, it’s not that far-fetched to suppose Benedetto got the Criminal Gene™ from him.

Literally changed his name to hide his compromising origins (as much as humanly possible in the spheres he frequents).

Burnt Edmond’s denunciation letter. Guess who else likes to burn things?

Is brought down by the literal unearthing of his biggest secret, which in turn concludes Benedetto’s arc.

Bertuccio:

Is, literally, the one who gave Benedetto life, and the emissary of Providence™ who shows up to bestow blessings upon him at semi-regular intervals.

Unfortunately, those gifts are always cursed. Surprise salvation from the grave in the garden? Only happens because Bertuccio tried to murder the kid’s father first, and results in what is functionally a kidnapping. Surprise adoption? Results in Benedetto being raised by a literal criminal, who is #shocked when his protege starts hanging out with ill-intentioned older boys and disciplines him with what we can reasonably assume from the unreliable narration is the good old belt. Surprise life-changing information about his origins that Bertuccio held onto all these years? Only revealed to cement Benedetto’s status as Monte-Cristo’s puppet.

Crumbled the second Benedetto questioned his ascendance, therefore drawing a clear link between authority and paternity and reinforcing the kid’s desire to defy both.

“Major Cavalcanti”:

Is just Some Guy™.

And yet, they have so much in common: both are impostors trapped in Monte-Cristo’s web, both are passionate about scamming rich people. There’s a quasi-instantaneous recognition between the two and, because they share the same goal, they develop a strangely wholesome understanding…? It’s forced coexistence as much as it is respect, but it’s not deprived of a weird sort of warmth, and Monte-Cristo himself comments on how much it looks like actual familial love. The contrast with Caderousse could not be harsher.

In virtue of his fake wealth and fake fatherhood, the Major becomes the Ultimate Authority™ ‘Andrea’ name-drops every time he wants to advance in society.

Caderousse:

Outwardly, he adopts all the attributes of a good father. He taught Benedetto most of his tricks! He feeds him! He talks of all the hardships they’ve been through together, like a family would!

But, of course, what he’s really doing is blackmailing Benedetto. Caderousse wants money, and it’s taken him a while to actually get his hands dirty, but he’s finally graduating to murder! And his silly young friend should help him if he doesn’t want his blood spilled on Place de Grève.

Anyway Benedetto stabs that guy real bad. I thought it was hilarious of him.

Danglars:

As Andrea’s future father-in-law, Danglars is his ticket towards the life of luxury without effort he has always wanted.

Of course, Danglars is using Andrea for the same reason Caderousse uses Benedetto: for money. Both of them lie about what they own, ergo about who they are, to get their hands on what they think the other has. This is especially interesting when put in perspective with the brutal honesty Danglars employs when talking to Eugénie, who he treats like a son and almost business partner rather than like a daughter (Transmasc Eugénie Truthers, rise up!).

… But of course, he still wants people to think of he and Andrea as family to strengthen his own nobility: if his son (in-law) is a prince, a title Danglars repeats ad nauseam, doesn’t that make him a king?

All things considered, despite losing their freedom (temporarily in Danglars’ case), money and status, both of them get a relatively happy ending compared to most of the cast.

Monte-Cristo:

BUCKLE UP THIS IS THE MOST INTERESTING.

Twice Benedetto raises the possibility of Monte-Cristo being his biological father, a perfectly logical conclusion in light of what he has done for him; in turn, Monte-Cristo recognises Benedetto as one of God’s punishers, a title he otherwise only attributes to himself.

Both of them went through a symbolic rebirth after being buried alive.

Both of them were wrongly accused of being evil incarnate, but eventually graduated to Full-On Criminals. Talk about self-fulfilling prophecies.

Escape Artists™

Both had to completely reinvent themselves, down to their names and origins, to achieve their ambitions.

Ruined engagement ceremony!!! This also draws parallels to Villefort and, interestingly, to Valentine and Franz.

THIS:

🇫🇷 « Ce calme, cette parfaite aisance firent comprendre à Andrea qu’il était pour le moment étreint par une main plus musculeuse que la sienne, et que l’étreinte n’en pouvait être facilement brisée. »

🇬🇧 « This calm, this perfect poise told Andrea that he was presently held by a hand far stronger than his, whose grip could not be escaped easily. »

Both Edmond and Benedetto know they are prisoners of people more powerful than they are, of the narrative, of a superior power that wields them like knives; both Monte-Cristo and Andrea accept their role as knives in the hope of eventually slicing through their ties. Whether or not they succeeded in the end is up to the reader’s interpretation.

More Posts from Syrups-against-enver-gortash and Others

I Tried To Make A Venn Diagram But My Migraine Is Ironically Too Bad For Me To Have The Brain Power To

i tried to make a venn diagram but my migraine is ironically too bad for me to have the brain power to take the time to fix the proportions and then i locked one of the text layers and got pissed off and gave up. but i kind of like it all fucked up like this

Home Alone But In Lesmis

home alone but in lesmis

Just wait for season 2 crashout mulder buddy you are not ready

okay hi I've started x-files and omg Dana is so season 1 Jon and I'm not going insane am I

Shoutout To Roger Allam Javert. Idk What They Did To Him With The Makeup But He Looks Dead. I Fucking

Shoutout to Roger allam Javert. Idk what they did to him with the makeup but he looks dead. I fucking love it.


Tags
Hey @aroseinmisery1248 Heres Your Eponine! Color Palette From This List If You'd Like To Send An Ask

Hey @aroseinmisery1248 heres your eponine! Color palette from this list if you'd like to send an ask ^^

do you think every cardinal has a hypothetical pope name already chosen in their head

i am nooooot locked the fuck in. im locked the fuck out. call the locksmith

scully would secretly love ethel cain

Dudddde what if we were foils and you were beautiful and i was ugly and you have revolution in your eyes and i believe in nothing and you chastely drop your eyes at all things that were not the republic and i stare fixedly at all women and you were absolute in your ideas and i was shapeless and you pitied me and i venerated you and you scorned me and i admired you and you disdained me and i loved you. What if in the presence of you i became someone once more, what if i was charmed by your chaste, healthy, firm, upright, hard, candid nature without me being clearly aware of it and without the idea of explaining it to myself occurring, what if i had need of you, what if i were your unaccepted pylades what if bro can you hear me


Tags
  • syrups-against-enver-gortash
    syrups-against-enver-gortash reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • syrups-against-enver-gortash
    syrups-against-enver-gortash liked this · 1 week ago
  • motovilka
    motovilka liked this · 2 months ago
  • bluhgggggggfff
    bluhgggggggfff liked this · 2 months ago
  • ilvevi21
    ilvevi21 liked this · 2 months ago
  • pegasusdrawnchariots
    pegasusdrawnchariots liked this · 2 months ago
  • sharkboyeli
    sharkboyeli liked this · 3 months ago
  • tanilealto
    tanilealto liked this · 3 months ago
  • paradiseillusory1998
    paradiseillusory1998 reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • paradiseillusory1998
    paradiseillusory1998 liked this · 3 months ago
  • tsarputte91
    tsarputte91 liked this · 4 months ago
  • after-perfect
    after-perfect reblogged this · 4 months ago
  • holygoldfish
    holygoldfish liked this · 4 months ago
  • artemis2110
    artemis2110 liked this · 4 months ago
  • ninadove
    ninadove reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • octubreazul
    octubreazul reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • octubreazul
    octubreazul liked this · 5 months ago
  • none-ofthisnonsense
    none-ofthisnonsense reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • none-ofthisnonsense
    none-ofthisnonsense liked this · 5 months ago
  • forsuperbang
    forsuperbang reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • songwoongmink
    songwoongmink liked this · 5 months ago
  • saintplutosleepwalker
    saintplutosleepwalker reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • hopeforthbest
    hopeforthbest liked this · 5 months ago
  • after-perfect
    after-perfect liked this · 5 months ago
  • kitschy-gillyflowers
    kitschy-gillyflowers reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • kitschy-gillyflowers
    kitschy-gillyflowers liked this · 5 months ago
  • skyeventide
    skyeventide liked this · 5 months ago
  • eleancrvances
    eleancrvances reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • lowlansworld
    lowlansworld liked this · 6 months ago
  • unknown-heir
    unknown-heir reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • saintplutosleepwalker
    saintplutosleepwalker reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • tvar-i
    tvar-i reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • tvar-i
    tvar-i liked this · 6 months ago
  • natchy09
    natchy09 reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • natchy09
    natchy09 liked this · 6 months ago
  • belamolei
    belamolei liked this · 7 months ago
  • sprintingpen
    sprintingpen liked this · 7 months ago
  • ladysecretik
    ladysecretik liked this · 7 months ago
  • edettethegreat
    edettethegreat reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • ninadove
    ninadove reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • edettethegreat
    edettethegreat reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • edettethegreat
    edettethegreat liked this · 7 months ago
  • chateau-dilf
    chateau-dilf liked this · 7 months ago
  • strigas-and-upirs
    strigas-and-upirs liked this · 7 months ago
  • old-man-ghost
    old-man-ghost liked this · 7 months ago
  • forsuperbang
    forsuperbang reblogged this · 8 months ago
  • forestelfin
    forestelfin reblogged this · 8 months ago
  • forestelfin
    forestelfin liked this · 8 months ago

34 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags