Something That Bothers Me Upon Re Reading The Aftermath Of Snape’s Worst Memory Is How Little It Actually

Something that bothers me upon re reading the aftermath of Snape’s Worst Memory is how little it actually focuses on Snape’s trauma and suffering. I touched on it briefly in the past but Harry’s thoughts and discussion afterwards centre around how he is sad that his father was actually an arsehole. Sure there are brief moments of him empathising with Snape but really the narrative arc is: Harry is shook to see James being a prick, Harry mopes over it, He talks to Sirius and Lupin who reassure him with a very bias narrative and then continues to adore and praise his father. 

At no point does he think there might be at least some validity to Snape’s present hatred, instead he later uses it to blame Snape for Sirius’ death. Once again there is minimal recognition of Snape’s trauma and why he is the way he is and lets not even discuss how little regard Harry seems to have for Snape’s privacy, his only regret being that he got caught sneaking into the pensieve not that you know.. it was morally wrong. There is not attempt at apologising, at no point does Dumbledore or anyone else say “What you did was incredibly wrong” it is just brushed aside.

It feels very shallow to have Harry witness Snape being bullied by his father only to have him go right back to seeing him in the same adoring and unrealistic light and to have zero acknowledgment or empathy for Snape save for a few pages post memory and then claim this is “Harry seeing his Dad in a clearer light”.

More Posts from The-doe-prince and Others

1 year ago
the-doe-prince - Mak
the-doe-prince - Mak
the-doe-prince - Mak
the-doe-prince - Mak
the-doe-prince - Mak
the-doe-prince - Mak

Fyolai Duet.

Been listening to birds of death(the one Fyodor perform with his cello) the original piece has a piano duet so I've come to conclusion on drawing Nikolai with piano. :))

1 year ago
Nahyuta Presented To Followers.

Nahyuta presented to followers.

1 year ago
Comfort

Comfort

aand thats it! might do another batch of these another time but heres all i got of this for now, hope yall liked it lol

8 months ago

Kai, Nya and their Parents - The Difference between knowing and not knowing what you're missing - and the sacrifices made by a caring brother

Kai, Nya And Their Parents - The Difference Between Knowing And Not Knowing What You're Missing - And

The day Nya was brought home - the day Kai met Nya face to face for the first time; Kai is two (Hands of Time, episode 3, A Time of Traitors)

Kai, Nya And Their Parents - The Difference Between Knowing And Not Knowing What You're Missing - And

Three years later

Ray and Maya are kidnapped, thus forcing Kai to take on the responsibility of becoming a five year old Dad aka the death of Kai's babyhood and childhood so as to preserve Nya's babyhood and childhood (Hands of Time, episode 8, Pause and Effect)

Kai, Nya And Their Parents - The Difference Between Knowing And Not Knowing What You're Missing - And

Thirteen years later

Kai and Nya are reunited with their parents (Hands of Time, Episode 8, Pause and Effect)

Three years later (vid from Seabound, episode 2, The Call of the Deep)

Though Kai had pointed out that Nya and Maya did not get along (due to Nya's independence from having grown up without her parents); at Master Wu's insistence, Kai calls in his mother to help Nya with her power problem.

Nya, however, dislikes Maya's mothering (what she considers babying).

When Wu suggests that Nya should discuss her issues with Kai, Nya insists with scorn that Kai likely enjoys being waited on and loves to be treated like a baby.

(Note how Nya goes from the probability statement of "probably, likes, being waited on" to the presumption in her absolute statement of "I bet he loves being treated like a baby" -- Nya, please tell me if this is your thoughts on your brother who raised you and gave up everything for you then when has he ever previously behaved in such a way that would suggest your statements to be true.)

The difference here is that Kai remembers what it was like to have someone taking care of him only to have it ripped away - to go from being the baby boy to suddenly having to be the adult for his sister.

Nya, though, doesn't really remember what it was like to be cared for by her parents; but, she remembers what it was like to be cared for (by her brother).

Kai is, in a way, reveling in the joy of being able to play games with his father, eat food cooked by his mother, and learn once more from his parents.

Kai, Nya And Their Parents - The Difference Between Knowing And Not Knowing What You're Missing - And

All things he hoped for but never once thought he'd ever have again.

While growing up, Nya was likely allowed to play games, eat homemade food that she didn't have to cook, and learn from Kai the lessons that he remembers their parents teaching them.

Kai on the other hand, had to get straight to work, schedule time in a busy day to cook so that Nya could eat, and be the one to teach trusted lessons from his parents (while likely having to weed out good advice from bad, given to him by whichever random adult decided to give it to him).

Kai's sacrifices for Nya can even be seen in the clothes they wear in the pilot.

Kai, Nya And Their Parents - The Difference Between Knowing And Not Knowing What You're Missing - And

When we first see Nya it looks like she's dressed in silk clothes which we know didn't come from Maya's closet since she generally dresses in blue.

Kai, Nya And Their Parents - The Difference Between Knowing And Not Knowing What You're Missing - And
Kai, Nya And Their Parents - The Difference Between Knowing And Not Knowing What You're Missing - And

Kai on the other hand is introduced in his blacksmithing clothes and goes to train with Wu, in his blacksmithing clothes, which may indicate a limited closet - he may even be wearing his Father's clothes as a way to save money.

Kai, Nya And Their Parents - The Difference Between Knowing And Not Knowing What You're Missing - And

But, you might say, he has different clothes in the episode, The Royal Blacksmiths.

Kai, Nya And Their Parents - The Difference Between Knowing And Not Knowing What You're Missing - And

Yes, he does have different clothes, but these clothes, like his and the Ninja's matching pajamas (color coded but with the same golden dragon on the chest pocket) are likely the result of Kai now being able to lean on Wu, financially.

Note that Kai's clothes are the only ones that indicate his elemental power - the others likely already had these clothes on hand before they met Wu (except maybe Zane - IDK).

Another way Kai's sacrifices and generosity torwards his sister can be shown is by comparing the first pilot episode to the Season 2 episode 6, Wrong Place, Wrong Time.

In this episode it is shown that, were it not for Nya getting kidnapped by Garmadon, Kai would never had cared about becoming a ninja.

It was only the knowledge that becoming a ninja was the only way to save Nya that motivated Kai to become a ninja.

Yet in a timeline where Nya was never kidnapped, all Kai cared about was getting the blacksmith shop back on its feet after the Skulkin attack.

So how did Wu convince Kai to come to the Monastery, the answer, he didn't - Nya did.

Wu unintentionally convinced Nya to become a ninja and since Kai wasn't just going to let her go off on her own (this is his fourteen year old little sister who he raised after all) Kai went with her so they could become Ninja.

Kai gave up what he wanted in favor of what Nya wanted.

~~~~~

Kai's sacrifices, his giving nature, and everything he does for Nya is almost practically an automatic habit, because he and Nya lost their parents at a young age thus forcing Kai to give up being a child to be Nya's caretaker.

And yet throughout the series whenever the siblings bring up their parents, it becomes clear that Kai made sure that Nya never forgot them and that they were remembered well, that they were missed and not forgotten.

I really like Nya; and while Seabound is a great season it also points out that Nya may just be truly unaware of how much Kai sacrificed for her to the point where she doesn't understand exactly why Kai likes having their parents around; among other details that she and others misunderstand about Kai.

Believe me, I like the idea that Nya knows and helps her brother out where she can, and she definitely loves him, but it seems like Seabound has shown her to be unaware of Kai's trials and tribulations in raising her and keeping them both from landing in the grave of the fireflies.


Tags
1 year ago
What If...

What if...

1 year ago

Thinking about Snape’s patronus being a doe.

Thinking about how Snape’s patronus was not another stag to compete for the doe’s affection. It was another doe, a fellow doe.

Thinking about how Snape’s patronus might have been something else before. A bat maybe? But it changed to a doe.

Thinking about how Snape loved Lily. Probably at one point it was infatuation, a crush. Do we have to limit it to just unrequited love though? The platonic love wasn’t unrequited. I don’t think Lily stopped thinking of Severus as a friend, even to her dying breath. Childhood best friends just don’t leave you like that.

Thinking about Severus Snape promising to be Dumbledore’s right hand man. Thinking about Severus Snape at his first Order meeting, sitting awkwardly alone, apart from everyone. No one in his life ever showed him how to be good. Except one person.

Thinking about Severus Snape trying to emulate Lily Evans as he tried to choose the right. Trying to remember the way she stood up for what she believed in. Failing over and over and over again. Making snide remarks, throwing out slurs, physically harming those he disagreed with. Every time with Lily’s voice in the back of his head, reprimanding him. Knowing he could never do right by her. But always trying again. Always.

Thinking about Severus Snape realizing slowly and all at once how wrong his youthful ideas about muggles and wizards had been. How stupid he was for believing them in the first place. Wishing he could go back, choose better, try again. Knowing he can’t. Remembering Lily. Working harder to fix things. Still failing in the little ways that make all the difference.

Thinking about Severus Snape, a decade into his service, casting a patronus, expecting to see his little bat, and seeing her. Well, not her, but her patronus. A doe. His patronus. A doe.

Thinking about how Severus Snape’s patronus is a doe because he worked to become the friend he betrayed. To pay back his debt, to make things right however he could. To protect her son. Her son who he hated because he was the exact replica of Severus’ own childhood bully. But still her son. Her eyes. He had to protect her eyes, the eyes that were still watching, still disapproving.

“Look. At. Me.”

1 year ago
...One Discovery Always Seems To Lead To Another, Doesn't It?
...One Discovery Always Seems To Lead To Another, Doesn't It?
...One Discovery Always Seems To Lead To Another, Doesn't It?
...One Discovery Always Seems To Lead To Another, Doesn't It?
...One Discovery Always Seems To Lead To Another, Doesn't It?
...One Discovery Always Seems To Lead To Another, Doesn't It?
...One Discovery Always Seems To Lead To Another, Doesn't It?
...One Discovery Always Seems To Lead To Another, Doesn't It?
...One Discovery Always Seems To Lead To Another, Doesn't It?
...One Discovery Always Seems To Lead To Another, Doesn't It?

...One discovery always seems to lead to another, doesn't it?

(Based on the fact that Athena canonically can't distinguish romantic feelings which becomes a plot point several times lol)

For Ace Attorney Aspec Week - Realisation! @aspec-ace-attorney

1 year ago

Snape: this student is incompetent

McGonagall: that student is 12

Snape: that's not an excuse to be incompetent

1 year ago
We R Nearly Finished Replaying Aa3

we r nearly finished replaying aa3

  • no1dnnanthem
    no1dnnanthem liked this · 1 month ago
  • redmichelle1030-blog
    redmichelle1030-blog liked this · 4 months ago
  • nosferawrtuu
    nosferawrtuu liked this · 5 months ago
  • corvusprinceps
    corvusprinceps liked this · 9 months ago
  • nonjewishzionist
    nonjewishzionist liked this · 9 months ago
  • tozunaki
    tozunaki liked this · 11 months ago
  • poetryandbloods-blog
    poetryandbloods-blog liked this · 11 months ago
  • praisethemofftiss
    praisethemofftiss reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • praisethemofftiss
    praisethemofftiss liked this · 11 months ago
  • severus-snaps
    severus-snaps reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • heikimati
    heikimati liked this · 1 year ago
  • the-doe-prince
    the-doe-prince reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • the-doe-prince
    the-doe-prince liked this · 1 year ago
  • notsosecrettunnel
    notsosecrettunnel liked this · 1 year ago
  • kettleeye
    kettleeye liked this · 1 year ago
  • ourheroictommo
    ourheroictommo liked this · 1 year ago
  • susiesuzy
    susiesuzy liked this · 1 year ago
  • lucian-evander
    lucian-evander liked this · 1 year ago
  • bazmultifandom
    bazmultifandom reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • bazmultifandom
    bazmultifandom liked this · 1 year ago
  • here-queer-and-living-in-fear
    here-queer-and-living-in-fear liked this · 2 years ago
  • shrekross
    shrekross liked this · 2 years ago
  • tiphprince
    tiphprince reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • thecrowhunter
    thecrowhunter liked this · 2 years ago
  • greatbluesharky
    greatbluesharky liked this · 2 years ago
  • inc0rrect
    inc0rrect liked this · 2 years ago
  • itanevra
    itanevra liked this · 2 years ago
  • soulblack16-blog
    soulblack16-blog liked this · 2 years ago
  • thepaceperson
    thepaceperson liked this · 2 years ago
  • anis5240
    anis5240 liked this · 2 years ago
  • presidentbeifong
    presidentbeifong liked this · 2 years ago
  • kepler45ad
    kepler45ad liked this · 2 years ago
  • yumnasfunblogsaysfreesudan
    yumnasfunblogsaysfreesudan liked this · 2 years ago
  • ladyemeraldpigeon
    ladyemeraldpigeon liked this · 2 years ago
  • kitchen-box
    kitchen-box liked this · 2 years ago
  • insomniac-frog
    insomniac-frog liked this · 2 years ago
  • sal-fina
    sal-fina liked this · 2 years ago
  • touchmetouchmetouchme
    touchmetouchmetouchme liked this · 2 years ago
  • lilywillynilly1234
    lilywillynilly1234 liked this · 2 years ago
  • psychictrashmoon
    psychictrashmoon liked this · 2 years ago
  • why0should0i
    why0should0i liked this · 2 years ago
  • scaryspears
    scaryspears liked this · 2 years ago
  • ohbabyobeyme
    ohbabyobeyme liked this · 2 years ago
  • thenaturallygirl
    thenaturallygirl liked this · 2 years ago
  • tryingfrida
    tryingfrida liked this · 2 years ago
  • xoxopam4
    xoxopam4 liked this · 2 years ago
  • ariamaze0
    ariamaze0 liked this · 2 years ago

Instead of using my autism for productivity I use it to overanalyse fictional characters ☠️Might have ADHD too

174 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags