You Cannot Tell If An Author Is Straight Or Cis By Whether They Write “good Representation.”

you cannot tell if an author is straight or cis by whether they write “good representation.”

if you don’t want anyone to have to out themselves to defend their “right” to write about queerness, then when you encounter a queer narrative or character you dislike, you have to smack down assumptions that the person who wrote it wasn’t queer.

i keep talking about this because i think it’s important; and it’s certainly not the death of criticism. you can read a text critically without making assumptions about the author’s identity. you can talk about why you don’t find a piece of representation meaningful to you, why you think it’s badly written or even offensive. but if you say that it is any of those things because the author is straight or cis, no matter how obvious that may seem to you, you are out of bounds. i don’t have to go far to find examples of authors who have received that “feedback” and had to say “i’m sorry if i didn’t get this right, but i am a member of the lgbtq community.” sometimes they only realized they were queer because they wrote those stories. and this is also true for a lot of actors who have played queer roles, who have been accused of “stealing” those roles or not acting them convincingly and authentically.

i’ve seen the damage that causes and to me it’s not a game that’s worth playing.

More Posts from Eleven-pipers-piping and Others

3 years ago

Wet’suwet’en protesters face surveillance and harassment on Indigenous lands

4 years ago

I read Watership Down way too early as a child and I feel like that’s noticeable. 

3 years ago

again, israeli soldiers have invaded and launched brutal attacks against muslims worshipping inside the al-aqsa mosque - injuring children, women, and elderly with live bullets, tear gas, and grenades at innocent civilians worshipping in peace

every single ramadan this happens. every single year.

for those who aren’t muslim, please understand the significance of the timing and location. the al-aqsa mosque is one of the most holy sites in islam, and it’s currently ramadan, the holiest month of the year. it is intentional.

and this isn’t even getting into how many innocents have been killed since ramadan began, including children, elderly, and a disabled widow who supported her six children, now orphaned

i pray for a day when our holiest sites are respected and protected, and i pray for a day when the oppressed can spend their holiest days in peace and safety. i pray for an end to the occupation and it’s evil.

5 years ago

im sorry to drop this long ass post but i think i meed a second opinion

okay so all my native folks i have a dilemma and an existential crisis and im genuinely uncertain if im like, unintentionally trying to appropriate a culture i dont actually belong to, or if im trying to actively join my community.

so i am largely white, and i am translucent, and my moms side of my family is an amalgamation of french, abenaki, and i think some german. however, for the few years of my life where i was fully under my parents jurisdiction with little outside contact, i was sort of raised outside of culture. culture-adjacent. barely anything you could call heritage except for antique family photos, the occasional mention of a great grandparent, and addiction problems. no traditions. little community. barely any family stories. and when i finally started forming a personality around 7 or so, and meeting humans and talking to them i realized oh shit, everyone has like.... a place. a group.

my french canadian friends visit family in canada every summer, my british and irish friends visit the uk and shit, my portuguese friends eat portueguese food and do their hair different. the people born and raised in my middle of buttfuck nowhere massachusetts town are all the worst and going nowhere. my black friends have a group of friends that know what their life is like

and i was looking for my place as this lost 7 year old. i didnt fit with the hillbilly, learned to rode on a tractor family. i definitely didnt fit with the rich uptight texas family. i didnt fit with the town i was in. and i was going through my genealogy, and talking to my family members, and i learned about my abenaki family members. theyre kinda distant but i do feel liek i fit with them. am i doing a bad? is this internalized racism? im sleep deprived and struggling and i dont wanna hurt anyone or hurt anyone elses culture or insert myself where i dont belong please someone help


Tags
4 years ago
Times Are Troubling And Hard Right Now-but Never Forget, Your Beet Loving Grandmother Loves You Very
Times Are Troubling And Hard Right Now-but Never Forget, Your Beet Loving Grandmother Loves You Very
Times Are Troubling And Hard Right Now-but Never Forget, Your Beet Loving Grandmother Loves You Very
Times Are Troubling And Hard Right Now-but Never Forget, Your Beet Loving Grandmother Loves You Very
Times Are Troubling And Hard Right Now-but Never Forget, Your Beet Loving Grandmother Loves You Very
Times Are Troubling And Hard Right Now-but Never Forget, Your Beet Loving Grandmother Loves You Very
Times Are Troubling And Hard Right Now-but Never Forget, Your Beet Loving Grandmother Loves You Very
Times Are Troubling And Hard Right Now-but Never Forget, Your Beet Loving Grandmother Loves You Very
Times Are Troubling And Hard Right Now-but Never Forget, Your Beet Loving Grandmother Loves You Very

Times are troubling and hard right now-but never forget, your Beet loving Grandmother loves you very very much and wants you to be safe.

And for you to eat your vegetables.

5 years ago

im curious. put in the tags if you have siblings, how many and if you’re an only child, oldest, middle, or youngest. i feel like this tells a ton about you


Tags
5 years ago

REBLOG IF YOU ARE HELLA BORED AND WOULDN’T MIND SOME CURIOUS ANONS.

4 years ago

Please reblog if you think that “they/them/theirs” is a valid set of pronouns.

3 years ago

Help bring Indigenous horses home!

Hi all!

My friend is Ojibwe and a dedicated Indigenous researcher and activist. She recently has discovered a number of Ojibwe ponies (also known as the Lac La Croix pony) for sale by a white-owned farm. 

This is really important because these ponies are very important to the Ojibwe – these ponies are also the only known Indigenous-developed breed of horse in Canada, and there are only 200 left in the world. 

image

[Image: A girl sitting on an Ojibwe pony and hugging its neck. Image credit to Broadview.]

The fact that there are 200 left at all is incredible at all, because in 1977, Canada took the last known four ponies away to be destroyed, and they were rescued by an Ojibwe man living in Minnesota. 

Read more about the history here.

My friend is arranging to have five of these horses brought back home to the Ojibwe, and her elders are already planning a welcome ceremony for these horses. If anyone has anything to spare, it would be a huge help to bring them home. 

Donate here!

Alternately, you can get the horses a gift from their wishlist! 

  • allegroandoldlace
    allegroandoldlace liked this · 2 years ago
  • rakshasi-sue
    rakshasi-sue liked this · 2 years ago
  • lebelinoria
    lebelinoria liked this · 2 years ago
  • universe-unwinding
    universe-unwinding reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • universe-unwinding
    universe-unwinding liked this · 2 years ago
  • m-has-a-blog
    m-has-a-blog reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • annabb12
    annabb12 liked this · 2 years ago
  • aavas-raven-wings
    aavas-raven-wings liked this · 2 years ago
  • heteroeroticsubtext
    heteroeroticsubtext liked this · 2 years ago
  • silentstep
    silentstep reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • tassliah
    tassliah liked this · 2 years ago
  • liz-squids
    liz-squids liked this · 2 years ago
  • leahazel
    leahazel liked this · 2 years ago
  • anghraine
    anghraine liked this · 2 years ago
  • pedanther
    pedanther liked this · 2 years ago
  • vaguely-none
    vaguely-none liked this · 2 years ago
  • bamboocounting
    bamboocounting liked this · 2 years ago
  • sqbr
    sqbr reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • maraleestuff
    maraleestuff liked this · 3 years ago
  • geeky-karo
    geeky-karo liked this · 3 years ago
  • honestmrdual
    honestmrdual liked this · 3 years ago
  • overthinkingaj
    overthinkingaj reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • princesshalfdemon
    princesshalfdemon liked this · 3 years ago
  • cmdthenerd
    cmdthenerd liked this · 3 years ago
  • gregorsamsapost-trans-formation
    gregorsamsapost-trans-formation reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • loveisnotunrequited
    loveisnotunrequited liked this · 3 years ago
  • aantinous
    aantinous reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • spectershaped
    spectershaped reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • fierifreak
    fierifreak liked this · 3 years ago
  • stickmarionette
    stickmarionette liked this · 3 years ago
  • belosers
    belosers reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • rohmulijasu
    rohmulijasu liked this · 3 years ago
  • thestarsintheknight
    thestarsintheknight reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • fairytalesandimaginings
    fairytalesandimaginings liked this · 3 years ago
  • emit-ring
    emit-ring liked this · 3 years ago
  • pilwsy
    pilwsy reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • voguementhols
    voguementhols reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • voguementhols
    voguementhols liked this · 3 years ago
  • dahhnald-duck
    dahhnald-duck reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • blaahhh123
    blaahhh123 liked this · 3 years ago
  • zmtn
    zmtn liked this · 3 years ago
  • silverskyy
    silverskyy reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • spectershaped
    spectershaped liked this · 3 years ago
  • metalcherry
    metalcherry reblogged this · 3 years ago
eleven-pipers-piping - This Is Just Stuff I Like And Whatnot
This Is Just Stuff I Like And Whatnot

Pip, they/them, nonbinary, panromantic, greysexual. This is sort of a junk blog, but its also my main one. I really use @woodwind-goddess so you should head over there

165 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags