The Truth. 🙏🏻

The truth. 🙏🏻

Miranda: Forever Invisible

This is going to be long and kind of rambly because I didn't feel like editing it. Also: here be spoilers.

There's something terrible and interesting about the way Miranda is doomed to be a ghost in her own story, the fandom, and Treasure Island (because she's not canonical, despite the connection between BS and TI). She is both haunted by and haunts the narrative; she is largely absent from meta-discussions (I have not seen a SINGLE post about her outside of Tumblr); and has minimal presence in fanvids/fanart/fanfic (Madi suffers from a similar affliction but for different reasons).

It's both frustrating and also so fascinating that both textually and fandom-wise Miranda is most present when she isn't. When people write metas about Flint and grief post s2, and how SilverFlinty it is that John helps him through his depression and suicidal tendencies, or even just bemoan the loss of his hair-- that's all because of her. Her love and loss drive the plot in a very real way that, if you know what to look for, is undeniable but invisible to outsiders. The outline of her (like Thomas) is there.

Miranda changes Flint's path at least four times directly that we know of (seducing him, telling him about Lord Alfred Hamilton's ship's location, the Boston Pardons situation, and persuading him to go to Charles Town). Whether that's acknowledged by fans or not, it's true. After my first rewatch, when I actually knew the full story, I got that Flint cared for her from the beginning. But in case I hadn't, it became explicit and unavoidable after her death. In s3e3, Flint tells Miranda's ghost/hallucination/spirit: "When I lost Thomas, I raged. I was distraught. I wept. But with you, I’m ruined over you." Just because their love was quieter doesn't mean it was less important.

I would personally lean toward describing Flint as Bi if you pressed me to assign him a modern sexuality (rather than thinking of homosexuality/queerness as an act like it often was historically), but I've never been 100% certain of that. (Just like BS' ending. Does John Silver [redact] Flint or [redact] him to [redacted]???). Like a lot of the show, it's open to interpretation.

However, I do think it is disingenuous to point to the one explicit and full sex scene we get between Flint and Miranda and say, "He's clearly gay! Look how bad their sex is." I think the 1705 flashbacks show enough physical chemistry that that isn't a solid argument. Also, I (and others too) read that one bad-sex scene as a reflection of their mutual grief over Thomas. Plus, even if Flint was only sexually/romantically interested in men, he still loves Miranda and is in some kind of involved and mutually fulfilling (at least in the past) (queer platonic) partnership with her. He, Thomas, and Miranda are a trio. BS is full of queer trios: Jack/Anne/Max; Woodes/Eleanor (past / and &) Max; Silver/Madi (/ ? or &?) Flint.

This has been said before, and I'm sure better worded too, but it's also tragic how she never gets to be right and enjoy it. Flint very rarely enjoys being right (and you can debate to what extent he's right about many things; I think the War was entirely justified), but we're clearly meant to root for him. I'd say he morphs into more of an overtly positive figure mid-s3 onwards. Despite the show's tragedy, Flint gets to enjoy a few key and decisive victories. Miranda never does.

When she is arguably most victorious (chewing Peter Ashe a new one in Charles Town), she is killed. Miranda is anointed by her tragic foresight and becomes almost untouchable because of it, morphing into an Icon, patron Saint of Lost Lovers, empty of personhood. And then, in season four, her house burns down, so there aren't even any mementos left. She's erased from the narrative physically and psychologically (who remembers her aside from Flint, Thomas, maybe Silver via proxy, and possibly Abigal Ashe)? Who writes posts about her, draws fanart of her, makes edits and videos with her? She's invisible. She's ignored. She's a ghost.

More Posts from Dragonsinthedarkness and Others

7 months ago

My goddess, this is the game I've been looking for AGES. Like...old shoujo style, with infinite references to well known characters and TAKARAZUKA ??? Plus, so beautifully written also in english with this amazing Phantom of the opera experience (with references also in the background music?!) ... I NEED the full version of it. Can't wait for it.

Thank you so so much for making this, is absolutely amazing.

🖤Exciting News! 🖤

🖤Exciting news! 🖤

🖤My free-to-play visual novel, "Phantom of the Black Rose Revue," is now available!🖤 This nostalgic yuri game features 19 animated CGs, 13 original music tracks, and an introduction to the world, mysteries, and love interests of the Revue! 🖤

Signal boosts greatly appreciated, especially as this game is entered in the Spooktober Game Jam!


Tags
3 years ago
The Untamed | Reunion
The Untamed | Reunion
The Untamed | Reunion
The Untamed | Reunion
The Untamed | Reunion

The Untamed | Reunion

8 months ago
“I Miss Him Too.“

“I miss him too.“

8 months ago

Lately I found myself thinking about James/Miranda relationship as a reversed version of Orpheus and Eurydice’s story, especially towards the end of it. Not because these two stories match well (they do not) but just because I like making this kind of classical comparisons and I'm stuck from a bit on the fact that, right before her death, for the first time Miranda was the one to refuse the progress to look back at the past. 

After the loss of Thomas, James let himself slip into a darkness comparable to the underworld, a darkness which so often threatened to swallow him whole. He walked on a thin line between a reign of death and an island of life, and if that darkness was that reign, Miranda was his island. 

During their whole journey of processing their grief and climbing their way back to a life that could be called such, she was the one always trying to drag him towards the light. To her, the life that might have been waiting for them in the future was that light, while the past was the darkness, and not because she deemed it forgettable or unimportant, quite the contrary indeed, but because while she knew how to keep and remember the beauty of that past and the light of it, along with the sorrow, she knew perfectly well how different it was for James. How he could remember the beauty of it, of course, but also knew how to put it aside in favor of the rage and the guilt, his gaze clouded by the pain and the unacceptable shame. 

She said it herself: she didn't want to forget that past, not the bright side of it and neither the inescapable sadness of it, its tragedy being the spring of that very beauty, the ruins existing only because there was something precious to be ruined in the first place; and at the same time, what could the dark of it matter, the injustice, the grudge, when it condemned the both of them to never be able to see the light again? 

First time I heard their discussion in ep.VII after knowing the whole story, I wondered how could she ask something like that of him, to forget and pass over what they had done to him just to gain a liveable life, but recently I've actually been wondering : how could she not?

I'm not taking any side in this, as I recognize Miranda's thoughts to be the most reasonable ones as they often are but at the same time I can't say I wouldn't act as stubbornly and desperately as James did in that situation, they're just really different ways to conceive one’s own existence, influenced by their own problems and conditions and mind. All I'm saying is that Miranda was able to see the light even if just from a distance, she was able to hope that one day they would have been able to truly see it. James was never. 

He just lied to himself about the possibility of it. He had plans and tactics and strategies, but for how I see it, those were all desperate attempts to convince himself of the contrary. He couldn't, maybe because of his personality, maybe because he knew that his situation wasn't one that could ever allow him to found real light in that world, maybe just because he loved her less than how much he had loved Thomas, less than how much she loved him, but whichever was the reason, he couldn't afford to see the light after that abyss, and I think Miranda was the first to know that. The one who knew him like no other, the one who loved him like no other. She knew that without help he would have never really been able to reach the end of that dark state of being. And she tried. She tried to help him in so many ways, because she loved him, she really did, and because she had the damn right to claim at least a decent life for herself. 

And here we come to the end, to Charles town.

Charles town could have been her success. Charles town was James’ surrender. For the first time she glimpsed one real chance of having him back, she saw in him the real intention to leave all of that darkness behind, to follow her, not leaving the past behind, never, but learning to move forward, finally allowing her a chance for a new life together. 

He was actually ready to accept even that miserable condition Peter Ashe imposed on him in order to get rid of the darkness, to climb to the light -as short lived as that might have been, at this point- to give Miranda a better alternative than the ones he had been able to grant her up until that moment (as I think his whole Charles town plan was led by the purpose of doing something to save her): as useless as we all know that would have been, accepting that bargain has probably been the most selfless thing James has ever done, even if he did it also for himself in a tired, desperate and contorted way. 

But Charles town wasn't only this to Miranda. 

Charles town was the discovery of the betrayal, because I believe she understood it all the moment she first saw that clock, I'm sure of it. Charles town was her umptheen attempt and her umptheen sacrifice. 

I think that must have been to her a similar quest to the Maria Aleyne's one: respecting James by telling him the truth, something he deserves to know, even knowing how he will react to it, knowing how impossible it would become for him, then, to go on with his plan, granting him a one way ticket to that darkness, or keeping him in the dark, bearing alone the weight of that knowledge, accepting to live with the helplessness to remedy that fatal injustice, only in the hope to finally make him reach that light?  

Would Orpheus reveal Eurydike a truth which risked pushing her back into the underworld just because it might be right for her to know it?

Still, things had been different, more desperate, back to the Maria Aleyne. Now the chance to succeed was real. 

And at first she made that difficult choice, which was selfish in a way, but definitely selfless in another, all at the same time.

And she did it because she loved him. 

She loved him so much that when she glimpsed, in that light, the prospect of losing him, she had to recognize that that light was -as James would have put it in the future- only their light, the light of a world the two of them couldn’t be part of anymore. 

She loved him so much that she had to look back. To the past, to him, because her James was still behind her, still in the dark, the only place where he was allowed to stay, and only that version of him was the one she truly loved. She loved the real James, with all his broken parts, not the one that could be seen under the lights of their lies. 

So she couldn't help giving up that false light, because she had wished for tranquility, a normal life -as probably anyone in her conditions would have done- but she was not disposed to give up the man she loved in order to gain that, as she hadn't been in the past, when the prospect of the future had been only dark and still she had not deserted the ones she loved. 

And when she turned back, this time trying to shield him from that light, the darkness at the pit ended up swallowing them both. 

Miranda died, and James was dragged back full force and imprisoned into the worst version of himself, the ruthless, autodestructive one. 

There are two versions of the story of Orpheus and Eurydice, and I think that the two of them taken together perfectly represent James’ reaction to her death and its circumstances.

In Virgilius’ one, Eurydice slightly resents Orpheus for his action, for his “folly” -as it is called- and (if we may call it that) for his selfish gesture of looking back, that she paid with her second chance to be alive. 

After Miranda's death, James dreams of her reminding him how he had resented her “because they were so close” and of course since that's a dream is what he knew he had felt. But that was…collateral to the condition he had been left stuck in. That was the childish resentment of having explicitly denied something he knew deep down he couldn't have. 

In Ovidius’ one instead Eurydice doesn't blame him because she can't resent being loved, and I think this is what James really felt. After all, looking straight at the truth of the situation and looking back at their shared history, I think there were no ways for him to actually, rationally resent her. (And in fact in his last dream about her she uses a past tense, “you resented me”, hinting that was something he had felt only in the moments when he was at his worst as when, always in the dream, he heard her apology).

Moreover, I think he perfectly understood the meaning of those last moments of hers, how important it was to her to make her voice be heard in that moment. In fact, despite the clear and growing doubt and rage (and worry) on his face while Peter and Miranda spoke, he didn't say a word, he let her speak, despite knowing the risks  and I think this is amazing and just proves how beautiful and respectful their relationship was, and that there were no way he could actually deem her responsible of their failure in that mission (doomed to failure since the beginning ‘cause of the truth).

What hurts even more about her death is the fact that it looks like they got closer to each other once again during that trip, as they hadn't probably been in years, and then…everything got lost forever.


Tags
4 weeks ago
Https://archiveofourown.org/works/64803721/chapters/166533523
Https://archiveofourown.org/works/64803721/chapters/166533523
Https://archiveofourown.org/works/64803721/chapters/166533523

https://archiveofourown.org/works/64803721/chapters/166533523

(Link also in comment)

My attempt at AgathaRio's backstory + Rio character study, inspired by mexican folklore, views of Death in literature, a lot of songs and my love for these two women.

Hope you'll like it.


Tags
6 years ago
#swanqueen #emmaswan #reginamills
#swanqueen #emmaswan #reginamills
#swanqueen #emmaswan #reginamills

#swanqueen #emmaswan #reginamills

#swanqueen #emmaswan #reginamills
#swanqueen #emmaswan #reginamills
#swanqueen #emmaswan #reginamills
#swanqueen #emmaswan #reginamills
10 months ago

They got me. Oh well...

Swanqueen In 3x21 ♥

swanqueen in 3x21 ♥

based on this:

Swanqueen In 3x21 ♥
7 months ago
✧・゚: *✧・゚:*  WANGXIAN  *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
✧・゚: *✧・゚:*  WANGXIAN  *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
✧・゚: *✧・゚:*  WANGXIAN  *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
✧・゚: *✧・゚:*  WANGXIAN  *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
✧・゚: *✧・゚:*  WANGXIAN  *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
✧・゚: *✧・゚:*  WANGXIAN  *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
✧・゚: *✧・゚:*  WANGXIAN  *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
✧・゚: *✧・゚:*  WANGXIAN  *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
✧・゚: *✧・゚:*  WANGXIAN  *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
✧・゚: *✧・゚:*  WANGXIAN  *:・゚✧*:・゚✧

✧・゚: *✧・゚:*  WANGXIAN  *:・゚✧*:・゚✧

5 years ago
You Didn’t Think I Was Gonna Miss This, Did You?
You Didn’t Think I Was Gonna Miss This, Did You?
You Didn’t Think I Was Gonna Miss This, Did You?
You Didn’t Think I Was Gonna Miss This, Did You?

you didn’t think i was gonna miss this, did you?

8 months ago

there's something to be said of flint's anger in the scene he beats singleton to death.

but.

i think we should recognize that part of it stems from strategy as well.

the conversation with billy at guthrie's house-

"but now it seems they feel i'm..." "too weak." "i was gonna say unlucky. so that's the thinking. we've been attacking ships with lighter loads because i'm too weak to do otherwise."

up until this moment flint didn't know that's how he was perceived. but now he does, and that he needs to prove to the crew that that's not true. and what better way to prove your strength than beating a man to death with your bare fists?

of course the anger played a huge role in it, i'm not going to deny it. but it didn't have to.

the puzzle pieces fit neatly together to set the scene. flint came into that fight with the full intent of unleashing that rage, not merely because he needed an outlet, but also because he knew it would help his image.

this, plus going after a ship like the urca...

afterwards, the crew could think what they wanted about flit's mental faculties. they could think what they wanted about his arrogance, his pride, his lies and schemes.

but not one of them would think him weak again.

Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
  • ray-gurl
    ray-gurl reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • aliceinhorrorland93
    aliceinhorrorland93 liked this · 3 months ago
  • steffigy
    steffigy liked this · 3 months ago
  • castiemrys
    castiemrys liked this · 3 months ago
  • itwillbeourswansong
    itwillbeourswansong liked this · 4 months ago
  • pseudole
    pseudole liked this · 5 months ago
  • ballisticbananas
    ballisticbananas reblogged this · 6 months ago
  • ballisticbananas
    ballisticbananas liked this · 6 months ago
  • ahauntedcorpse
    ahauntedcorpse liked this · 6 months ago
  • supernovacocorocha
    supernovacocorocha liked this · 6 months ago
  • honeycombtower
    honeycombtower reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • honeycombtower
    honeycombtower liked this · 7 months ago
  • captaimas
    captaimas reblogged this · 7 months ago
  • impressme-not
    impressme-not liked this · 7 months ago
  • gracegerald-blog
    gracegerald-blog reblogged this · 8 months ago
  • gracegerald-blog
    gracegerald-blog liked this · 8 months ago
  • uinu
    uinu liked this · 8 months ago
  • definitely-not-iorveth
    definitely-not-iorveth reblogged this · 8 months ago
  • definitely-not-iorveth
    definitely-not-iorveth liked this · 8 months ago
  • adriaticsea42
    adriaticsea42 reblogged this · 8 months ago
  • perpetualnausea
    perpetualnausea liked this · 8 months ago
  • malaiikka
    malaiikka liked this · 8 months ago
  • willowrosenblog
    willowrosenblog liked this · 8 months ago
  • tincan-man10
    tincan-man10 liked this · 8 months ago
  • corvuserpens
    corvuserpens reblogged this · 8 months ago
  • j-a-g-u-a-r-y-u
    j-a-g-u-a-r-y-u reblogged this · 9 months ago
  • melittarilow
    melittarilow liked this · 9 months ago
  • jenerallyreading
    jenerallyreading liked this · 9 months ago
  • isabellalinton
    isabellalinton liked this · 9 months ago
  • ursula-le-guin
    ursula-le-guin liked this · 9 months ago
  • lvsltsh
    lvsltsh liked this · 9 months ago
  • swansnotdead
    swansnotdead liked this · 9 months ago
  • friendofthefrogswastaken
    friendofthefrogswastaken liked this · 9 months ago
  • getthatmoodindigo
    getthatmoodindigo liked this · 9 months ago
  • mildyannoyingrabbit
    mildyannoyingrabbit reblogged this · 9 months ago
  • love4curset
    love4curset liked this · 9 months ago
  • dangerhumming
    dangerhumming liked this · 9 months ago
  • toseehowthestoryends
    toseehowthestoryends liked this · 9 months ago
  • ellifromspace
    ellifromspace liked this · 10 months ago
  • thestagthatlovedthewolf
    thestagthatlovedthewolf liked this · 10 months ago
  • dragonsinthedarkness
    dragonsinthedarkness reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • dragonsinthedarkness
    dragonsinthedarkness reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • dragonsinthedarkness
    dragonsinthedarkness reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • dragonsinthedarkness
    dragonsinthedarkness reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • dragonsinthedarkness
    dragonsinthedarkness reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • dragonsinthedarkness
    dragonsinthedarkness reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • dragonsinthedarkness
    dragonsinthedarkness reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • dragonsinthedarkness
    dragonsinthedarkness reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • dragonsinthedarkness
    dragonsinthedarkness reblogged this · 10 months ago
  • dragonsinthedarkness
    dragonsinthedarkness liked this · 10 months ago
dragonsinthedarkness - Eleonora🏴‍☠️
Eleonora🏴‍☠️

She/her, writer, books lover (whichever, from every age and every nation) tv shows lovers (ouat, iwtv, black sails, hannibal, good omens...), anime, manga and danmei lover (mxtx especially), rock lover. Women lover. Earth lover. Ao3: https://archiveofourown.org/users/EleonoraParker/works

196 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags